Your baby’s safety is probably one of the top things on your mind right now. And the fact is, that the mattress is one of the most important purchases you’ll make when putting together your nursery. So it’s natural that you’ll want to choose the best baby crib mattress for your baby.
-Don’t risk your baby’s safety. Learn how to pick out the best mattress for your baby.
Infants will spend on average 16 hours a day in their crib, which makes safety and comfort a big concern. Not all crib mattresses are safe, and there is some misleading information out there. To help you in your journey for a safe mattress for your baby, I’ve put together a guide and list of the best crib mattresses. I’ve done all of the long hours of research so you don’t have to!
The importance of choosing the best baby crib mattress
Making sure that your baby has the best baby crib mattress is very important for a couple of main reasons. Firstly, it makes sleeping in the crib much more comfortable for your baby. And a baby that is comfortable sleeps better than one that is not! Proper sleep is very important for baby and mom alike. Secondly, and most importantly, it provides a good support for baby’s growing body. Supporting baby in a healthy way is monumental in baby’s growth and development.
It’s important to use a specialized baby crib mattress; a mattress that is meant for adults or older children will likely not be the correct size for a crib, nor will it be firm enough. A mattress needs to fit snugly in the crib, with no large gap between the side of the mattress and the crib frame. If there’s a large amount of space, the mattress is too small and can be a suffocation and entrapment hazard.
Babies will spend up to 70% of their life on the crib mattress. That’s a lot of time! When you consider it that way, it’s easy to see why it’s important to choose the best baby crib mattress for your baby.
The Best Baby Crib Mattress
I’d like to quickly cover what most people came to this site looking for, the best baby crib mattress for your baby. Here I will cover each category with what the best crib mattress is. These have been highly praised by parents across America and being the best in terms of baby’s safety and comfort.
Best Natural Foam Crib Mattress
The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core is the original soy enhanced foam crib mattress. I can see why it’s one of America’s favorite crib mattresses.
This crib mattress is an ultra firm. This means that it won’t sink in and be a danger to baby. It’s been tested for firmness, durability, chemical content and air quality to ensure a safer sleeping environment for babies.
The pearl embossed cover is waterproof and easily wipes clean of all of those spills and stains that babies can make without needing a mattress cover. (Yay one less thing to buy!) Plus, stains and liquids won’t seep into the mattress since the binding is also waterproof!
It’s also very light, so it’s easy to carry and change the sheets (which is awesome, trust me!). The mattress maintains an average 4.6 / 5.0 star rating and over 300 reviews on Amazon, and remains one of their best-selling mattresses.
Best Budget Crib Mattress
The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is my top pick if you’re looking for a mattress that won’t break your budget.
This mattress offers plenty of firm support while also staying lightweight so that you can easily move and flip it when needing to change the sheets. Speaking of clean ups, that’s also something they had in mind. This baby mattress has a waterproof cover that wipes up in no time.
It’s also GREENGUARD CERTIFIED, meeting the standard for low-chemical emissions, so you can sleep easy knowing your baby will be tucked in safe and comfortable.
Best Organic Crib Mattress
My choice for the best organic mattress, Naturepedic No Compromise, is an all-round excellent crib mattress.
This mattress provides your baby with a natural, healthy, and comfortable sleep environment. Both the interior and exterior are made of 100% organic materials, and it uses absolutely no chemical flame retardants making it a safe choice for baby. Naturepedic also meets the strictest GREENGUARD certification standards for eliminating chemical emissions.
While it is not a budget mattress, it will safe you a ton of worry because you know with it your baby will be safe. Plus it can be used in a toddler bed, so you’ll get a few years of use out of it. This is an excellent mattress. It is 100% organic and guaranteed to be a great addition to your nursery. If you can afford to fit it into your budget, you’ll be happy that you bought it.
Best Memory Foam Crib Mattress
The Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress offers the perfect combination of comfort and support. The ultra thick luxurious high quality foam promotes a healthier and more restful sleep for baby.
The foam used for this mattress is naturally hypoallergenic, antimicrobial and resistant to allergens, mold, bacteria and dust mites. So if you have a family history of allergies, and are concerned that your little one will as well this is perfect for you.
An added benefit to this mattress is the air flow design. The mattress is also specifically designed to help baby regulate sleep temperature.
While this mattress is a bit pricy, the foam used is made only from the highest quality materials, meaning that it will be longer lasting and more comfortable than other standard budget mattresses.
What to Look For When Shopping for a Baby Crib Mattress
Width and length: In the United States, crib mattress sizes may range between 27 5/8″ to 28 5/8″ wide and 51 3/4″ to 53″ in length. This variation can mean an ill fitted crib and mattress combination. Keep this in mind when shopping for a crib. Your best option when buying a crib is to buy the mattress at the same time. This way you know that the mattress will fit the crib and not be a suffocation risk.
Depth: The depth of the crib mattress can vary quite a large amount. This fact can be a cause of much frustration for many new parents trying to find the best option for their baby. Coil crib mattresses tend to be on the thicker side—between 5 to 6″ and foam crib mattresses are more on the order of 4 to 6″. So how deep should a crib mattress be? There is no right or wrong answer. Choose a depth that fits well with your crib.
Firmness: A major point to keep in mind is that a firm mattress is preferred over a soft mattress for a baby mattress. In fact, the firmer that the mattress is the better it is. Soft sleeping surfaces create a suffocation hazard for infants and increase the risk of SIDS the leading cause of death in infants in the United States.
Fit: It’s also important to focus on whether the crib mattress fits snugly against the crib frame or not. A good rule of thumb to consider whether the mattress fits with the crib or not: If you can squeeze more than two fingers between the side of the mattress and the crib frame, the mattress is too small. A mattress that is too small is a suffocation risk for baby!
Types of Crib Mattresses
There are two main types of crib mattress that you need to know about. These are foam and innerspring. Both are safe mattress types for a baby mattress. Below you will find the differences between these two types of baby crib mattresses.
The foam crib mattress is made of polyurethane. It is a very popular choice for parents. As a bonus, it is generally cheaper than innerspring or organic options. Foam baby crib mattresses are available in a variety of different depths. The most popular depths for a foam mattress are between 3 and 6 inches.
They are also very lightweight which makes cleaning up baby messes and changing the sheets a much easier chore. A typical polyurethane baby mattress weighs approximately 7 – 11 pounds. Not bad at all!
Although an innerspring baby crib mattress is usually more expensive than a polyurethane one, it has a number of benefits.
The firm level of support provided by the coils is great for back support and safety; plus innerspring is one of the most popular choices for full size mattresses so if your baby likes innerspring as an infant, you have many more options when looking for a toddler or full sized mattress.
Comfort and support is measured in the number of coils inside. Common coil numbers are between 50 – 200; the more springs inside mean more cost, but this isn’t the only way to measure firmness.
Wire thickness, can also be a reliable way to measure firmness level. A lower gauge means thicker wire, which is stronger and therefore also firmer. For best results look for a mattress with a gauge of 15.5 or lower and 150 or more coils.
Why is buying a used crib mattress unsafe for a baby?
In the “British Medical Journal,” a study was published by Scotland researchers that showed a possible link between using a pre-owned crib mattress and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). The study found that an infant was up to three times more likely to die from SIDS when using a used crib mattress.
While the study did not find a firm cause-and-effect relationship, it did find sufficient evidence to warrant concern about accepting a used mattress from someone else’s home. It’s a risk that I firmly believe is not worth taking.
When buying a used crib mattress, you cannot be 100% sure of the care or abuse it went through while being used previously. Spills and diaper leaks can collect on a crib mattress and lead to moisture and mold growth if not cleaned properly.
Plus, if the crib mattress was not kept in a cool, dry place, moisture can seep into the mattress, harboring bacteria and fungal growth. Choose a new mattress for the safety of your baby and to ensure that you have the best baby crib mattress for your baby.
Loved this guide to the best baby crib mattress? Check out my related guides below!